Past Reviews

Regional Reviews: Cincinnati

Holiday Inn
La Comedia Dinner Theatre
Review by Scott Cain


The Cast
Photo courtesy of La Comedia Dinner Theatre
La Comedia Dinner Theatre always starts their last show of the year in early November. Because these shows typically have a Christmas theme, seeing them early in the run might feel too early for some. With this year's production, Holiday Inn, that isn't a problem. Though Christmas is certainly a major theme, Holiday Inn includes not one, but two Thanksgiving scenes, in addition to celebrating other festive dates on the calendar. La Comedia's production features a talented cast and well-suited direction, dances and design.

Holiday Inn is an updated version of the 1942 film of the same name. It's 1946, and showbiz song-and-dance man Jim wants to settle down; he buys the Mason Farm in Connecticut, quitting his performing trio. Jim's stage partners Ted and Lila (she's also Jim's fiancée) take another booking, with Lila planning to join Jim when the run concludes. Lila has a change of heart, and Jim meets local, former performer, Linda. Jim and Linda decide to transform the large farmhouse into a performing venue on holidays to make money to help pay the mortgage and taxes. The reappearance of Lila and Ted complicates matters–for both the budding romance between Jim and Linda and the future of Holiday Inn.

The book by Gordon Greenberg and Chad Hodge retains the general story from the film, but with smart changes to add more heart and laughs to strip away some of the outdated elements. Still, the plot is predictable and Act 2 drags, but it's also easy to follow and is a solid framework for an old-fashioned musical and its strong score.

That score features songs by Irving Berlin. The stage adaptation features some, but not all, of the songs from the film (several were wisely axed) plus additional songs from Berlin's catalogue. "White Christmas" is featured prominently, along with other standout and familiar numbers such as "Steppin' Out With My Baby", "Blue Skies", "Heat Wave", the charming "It's A Lovely Day Today", "Easter Parade", and "Cheek to Cheek".

Chris Bieser serves as the director and choreographer of this production, with Allison Gabert as assistant choreographer. The show moves at a brisk pace in Act 1 and has smooth transitions and the perfect tone throughout. The choreography features several stand out tap-dance numbers, and always hits the mark.

Scott O'Brien displays superb vocals and is a likeable lead as Jim. Stephanie Garcia Ochs is spunky and endearing as Linda, and is likewise a talented singer. As Ted, Sam Stickels is charismatic and shows off strong dance and vocal skills. Emily Thamm-Avsyuk skillfully captures the bubbly personality of Lila and dances well, but was pitchy vocally at the performance attended. As Louise, the Mason Farm farmhand, Blair Elizabeth Godshall puts her booming singing voice and comedic skills to great use, stealing several scenes. The remaining ensemble members are hardworking and provide worthwhile performances.

Scenic designer Gabe Davidson provides many period-appropriate set pieces which define the setting and time of year aptly. The lighting by Edward Huber is solid and includes an impactful fireworks effect. Costumes by Emercita Erb and Mattison Williams are appealing and varied.

Holiday Inn is a worthy new option for theatre companies to stage and a welcome addition to the November/December slot at La Comedia Dinner Theatre. The first-class score and solid story, combined with a praiseworthy cast, make this a holiday treat for theatregoers.

Holiday Inn runs through December 29, 2024, at La Comedia Dinner Theatre, 765 W. Central Ave, Springboro OH. For tickets and information, please visit lacomedia.com or call 937-746-4554.